The National Review reports,
Wiley-Blackwell, a major academic press, was set to release its four-volume
Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization
this month. According to the encyclopedia’s editor, George Thomas
Kurian, the set had been copy-edited, fact-checked, proofread,
publisher-approved, printed, bound, and formally launched (to high
praise) at the recent
American Academy of Religion/
Society of Biblical Literature conference. But protests from a small group of scholars
associated with the project have led the press to postpone publication,
recall all copies already distributed, and destroy the existing print
run. The scholars’ complaint? The
Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization,
they have reportedly argued, is “too Christian.” “They also object to
historical references to the persecution and massacres of Christians by
Muslims,” Kurian says, “but at the same time want references favorable
to Islam.”
The Catholic News Agency adds,
The encyclopedia’s Editor-in-Chief is filing two lawsuits against
the company to require the encyclopedia be published without removing
its “Christian content, tone and character.”
George Thomas Kurian, Editor-in-Chief of the Encyclopedia of
Christian Civilization (ECC), has circulated a letter protesting
Blackwell’s actions, which he calls a “looming crisis” in the
publication of the work.
The publisher's response?
Susan Spilka of Blackwell’s parent company John Wiley & Sons, Inc. responded to Kurian’s allegations in a statement, claiming that
concern about the content of the ECC had been raised in November 2008
prior to publication. Blackwell stated that the review was prompted by
concern for its “leading reputation as a publisher of high quality
scholarly content.”
... It described as an allegation “completely without foundation”
Kurian’s claim that the review is being driven by an “anti-Christian
lobby determined to ‘de-Christianize’ and censor the Encyclopedia.”
The lawsuits, of course, are still to be settled.